Who gets the stock? Channel allocation by cash timing

Rank DTC, wholesale and marketplace orders by when cash actually arrives, then reserve stock for the fastest payer. A worked example with real numbers.

Illustration for Who gets the stock? Channel allocation by cash timing

A wholesale order can look like your best sale of the month while quietly being the worst thing for your cash. It takes the stock today and pays in 60 days, while your DTC customer pays at checkout. When wholesale, DTC and marketplace orders all pull from one stock pool, the question is not how much to buy but who gets the units and when you get paid for them.

This post is a practical how-to for ranking channels by cash timing rather than margin alone. You will see why channel margin misranks your stock, how to work out when each channel actually pays you, and a simple rule for who gets the units. There is a worked example with one pool, three channels and real numbers, then how to apply the ranking to your own pool and what it changes in your buy plan. By the end you will know what to do before your next order, and why your buy plan and cash plan stop contradicting each other. The FAQs at the end cover the questions founders ask most.

Why channel margin alone misranks your stock

Wholesale is the channel that flatters your spreadsheet. A 45 day order shipped this week is cash in six weeks, while the same unit sold DTC is money in the bank this week. Margin per unit is a snapshot. Cash arrival is a schedule, and your supplier bill does not care which channel a unit was earmarked for when it lands.

Marketplace is the quiet version of the same problem. Payouts land on the platform's cycle with fees already deducted, so the gross sale value on the order line is not the number you can spend.

So two plans get built on one pool and never meet. The buy plan runs on margin per unit. The cash plan runs on payment dates. By mid month both look wrong and neither is, because they are answering different questions with the same units.

Before you set either, get clear on what each order does to your cash by working through what a stock order can actually afford. That is the gap the next section fills.

Work out when each channel actually pays you

Margin told you what each sale is worth. This tells you when it is money.

ChannelDates (order or invoice to payout)Days to cashCash per unit after fees
DTCCheckout to Shopify payout dateInclude settlement lag and holdsPayout net of fees
WholesaleInvoice or delivery date, per contract, to due dateIllustrative: 30, 45 or 60Invoice value
MarketplaceSale to settlement report dateInclude rolling reserveSettlement after fees

Check your actual Shopify payout schedule, not instant. For wholesale, the clock is your terms; the trigger is invoice or delivery date, whichever the contract names. For marketplaces, the platform sets the cycle; read your settlement report: fees come out first, and newer sellers may sit behind a reserve. Census counts a sale as e-commerce when order or terms are negotiated online, even if payment is not made online, so a channel is not a payment date. Put those dates into a 13-week cash flow forecast before ranking.

A ranking rule for who gets the units

Now you have days to cash written down, use it to rank the pool. Sort by cash arrival first, then by margin only within the same week. That one change fixes most of the contradiction between your buy plan and your cash plan.

cash weighted value per unit = margin per unit / days to cash

units reserved for a channel = floor allocation + share of the remaining pool

The share can follow forecast demand, but the floor is the important bit. Give your fastest payer a floor, not first refusal when stock gets tight. A floor stops a large wholesale order quietly eating your DTC stock in peak.

Set a cut off. Do not hold units for a channel whose cash lands after your next supplier payment unless you can name the money that covers the gap. And group units by the week the cash lands, not the week you ship. Stock leaves in one week and pays in another, so state both. This is the cash-aware method in Inventory Planning for Ecommerce.

A worked example: one pool, three channels, real numbers

Put the rule on one SKU. Say you hold 1,000 units with a landed cost of £18 each. These figures are illustrative, so swap in your own cost and selling prices before you use them.

DTC sells at £45, pays in 2 days, margin £27. Marketplace sells at £38 with roughly 15% in fees, so about £32.30 lands in 14 days, margin about £14.30. Wholesale sells at £33, no fees, margin £15, but cash in 45 days on those terms.

On margin per unit, wholesale comes second, ahead of marketplace. Divide margin by days to cash and the order flips.

ChannelMargin per unitDays to cashCash weighted value
DTC£27.002£13.50 per day
Marketplace£14.3014£1.02 per day
Wholesale£15.0045£0.33 per day

Wholesale goes from second to last. Use that ranking when the pool is short, then check the order size against your cash with how much stock to order.

Applying the ranking to the pool

Apply the ranking to the pool next. Reserve 400 units for DTC, 400 for marketplace and 200 for wholesale, because DTC is the fastest cash and wholesale has to be funded for six weeks.

Now say the wholesale account asks for 500 units. The extra 300 come out of DTC stock. You are trading 300 units worth up to 13,500 in cash within a couple of days for 9,900 arriving at day 45. That gap, roughly 3,600 in cash timing, is what you test against the forecast, not the wholesale order total.

Say yes only if you can name the money that carries you to day 45. Run the gap through the stock order affordability calculator before you commit, and read up on cash flow forecasting and stock cover so the trade is one you can actually fund.

What this changes in your buy plan

With the ranking applied, your buy plan needs three changes. First, reorder points move from per SKU to per channel. The same stock position can be healthy for wholesale and short for DTC, so a single trigger hides the difference. Set one per channel, using lead time and sales rate for each, as covered in Reorder point: how to set one per SKU without overbuying. Second, size the buy against the cash plan. Units you commit to now must be paid for by cash landing before the supplier bill, so read the buy plan and the forecast together, not in separate tabs. Test the gap before you order. Third, treat a wholesale upsell as a funding question. A deposit on order, staged deliveries or shorter terms on a first order all move the cash arrival date without touching the price. When those three plans stop contradicting, you want one place where the cash forecast sees the stock and the stock plan sees the bank. Cushion reads bills, balances and payment terms, with read-only connections to Shopify, Xero and QuickBooks. Join the waitlist.

What to do before your next order

The buy plan now carries cash dates, so write the allocation rule down where your next purchase order can see it. This week, write one line per channel: DTC, marketplace, wholesale, and the days from sale to cleared cash. That line is the ranking rule, and most founders have never put it on paper.

Set a floor for your fastest payer and hold it, even in the week a wholesale order looks irresistible. Before you say yes to a large wholesale order, name the cash that covers the gap to the payment date and check it against your cash flow forecast. If you cannot name it, the order is not funded.

Redo the ranking when terms or payout cycles change, usually once a season. Keep the old version so you can see what moved.

FAQs

Should you decline wholesale?

Only when it empties your fastest channel and you cannot fund the gap. A deposit fixes that.

How do you find your payout cycle?

Read your settlement report, then count sale-to-cash days. Use net, not order value.

What if wholesale pays late?

Rank it lower until it rebuilds a history. Chase on the due date.

Does margin still matter?

Yes, between channels paying on similar dates. Cash timing decides when short.

Should you split stock per channel?

Splitting helps reporting, not cash. The units are shared.

How often should you redo the ranking?

When terms or payouts change, and before peak season. Quarterly is enough.

Conclusion

When stock is short, cash timing ranks who gets the units first. Margin still decides between channels that pay in the same window. Keep one shared pool and allocate it deliberately, with a floor for your fastest payer. Write the ranking down, date it, and review it quarterly and before peak buying seasons.

That is the whole discipline: one pool, two numbers, and a dated plan. The value is fewer late-night guesses about who gets stock and more deliberate decisions you can defend. The next step is to see how Cushion brings your cash forecast and stock plan into one view, with read-only connections to Shopify, Xero and QuickBooks. Join the waitlist and make your next order a cash-aware one.

Filed underInventory PlanningCash Flow
Rory McLaughlan
Written by

Rory McLaughlan

Runs a Shopify store selling mystery football shirt boxes across the UK, EU and US. Built Cushion after years of joining up a cashflow sheet, a stock sheet and a sales forecast in his head every Sunday night.

See whether the next reorder leaves enough cash

Cushion puts your cashflow, stock and sales forecast on one screen, with read-only connections to your store, your books and your bank.